This patient was diagnosed with PRES caused by secondary hyperaldosteronism and milk-alkali syndrome with hypercalcemic crisis. Licorice contains glycyrrhizic acid which inhibits 11-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase, responsible for converting cortisol to cortisone. Elevated cortisol levels produce a pseudo-hyperaldosteronism state, causing secondary hypertension. Calcium carbonate, in excess, can precipitate milk-alkali syndrome. The associated hypercalcemia can induce elevations in blood pressure through various mechanisms. Licorice and hypercalcemia have each been suggested in the literature as a rare precipitant of PRES. This case highlights a patient presenting with two rare etiologies of PRES, likely exacerbating his risk for development. The importance of a thorough history including supplements and non-prescription medications is brought to light in this case. Early recognition and treatment of PRES is crucial to symptom resolution and minimizing long term complications.