Where’s the Vision? Introducing MULES and SUN to Concussion Testing in a Youth Ice Hockey Cohort
Alani Jack1, Christina Marini1, Scott Grossman1, Steven Galetta1, Laura Balcer1
1Neurology, NYU Grossman School of Medicine
Objective:

Vision comprises 50% of brain pathways; these are frequently involved in concussion.  Yet, vision assessment is limited in current concussion testing.  We introduced two quick, simple and accessible vision-based tests to youth ice hockey athletes.  We examined the relation of MULES (Mobile Universal Lexicon Evaluation System, picture naming) and SUN (Staggered Uneven Number) test scores to age in youth athletes.

Background:

The MULES and SUN were developed for concussion yet also identify patients with mild cognitive impairment, multiple sclerosis, and Parkinson’s disease.  The MULES and SUN have not been introduced for baseline and sideline testing in sports.

Design/Methods:
Laminated 8.5x11-inch test card versions of MULES and SUN were administered in a youth hockey league during pre-season.  Two trials of each test were completed; the best (fastest) of the test times was recorded as baseline.  
Results:

Among 103 youth athletes (median age 12 years [range=5-17]), average best times were 51 seconds (range=28-163) for MULES and 68 seconds (range=36-330) for SUN.  Learning effects, common for timed measures, were noted between trials 1 and 2 for the MULES (median improvement 8.1 seconds [range=-31-58], p<0.001, Wilcoxon signed-rank test).  Learning effects for the SUN, however, were, on average, absent (median improvement=0 [range=-94-58], p=0.39).  While both MULES and SUN showed progressively faster times with increasing age (R-squared=0.59, p<0.001 for MULES; R-squared=0.81, p<0.001 for SUN, nonparametric regression models), associations of younger age with slower test times were substantially greater for MULES (model effect=-5.4) vs. SUN (model effect=0).  

Conclusions:
MULES and SUN are practical vision tests to add to current concussion testing.  Pre-season baseline scores should be obtained given substantial associations of young age with slower test times. Differences in age related times on MULES vs. SUN provide evidence that picture and number naming capture separate aspects of complexity and function of brain pathways.
10.1212/WNL.0000000000211894
Disclaimer: Abstracts were not reviewed by Neurology® and do not reflect the views of Neurology® editors or staff.